Dietmar Rabich, “Kreta (GR), Rethymno, Fortezza, Theater,” Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.
In latest months I’ve been listening to Benjamin Britten’s String Quartet No. 2 (1945) and attempting to explain one thing, something, about it. Describe appears too weak a phrase when there exist lengthy formal analyses of the piece: nonetheless, evaluation appears simple, and outline way more troublesome.
It may be a vocabulary and grammar and syntax subject: I’m unsure we’ve got any of these for music like this. Mervyn Cooke says of the primary motion: “The general impact … is very uncommon.” That is the reassuring resignation of a music author.
***
Roland Barthes: “Music, by pure bent, is that which without delay receives an adjective.”
Sure, the Britten quartet is extremely uncommon. Its secret is C main. The uncommon moments after we actually get this chord really feel like a quick truce, a favor granted to us to grab a breath of acquainted air. In any other case it strikes relentlessly via accidentals and harmonies. Via time signatures, too: however the beat is fixed, virtually innocuously current and apparent: you can do a spin class to the propulsive beat of the scherzo. It defies us to seek out anything amiss: here’s a pulse, what extra might you need?
***
The piece is illegible, I feel. Britten appears to be studying aloud, fairly fluently, from one thing we didn’t acknowledge could possibly be learn in any respect. It’s—if not untranslatable—at the very least untranslated.
***
Leonard Bernstein stated of Britten’s music: “There are gears which can be grinding and never fairly meshing, they usually make an ideal ache.”
(Insert obligatory point out right here of Britten’s homosexuality and pacifism, and ensuing social alienation. Insert obligatory countermention of his enduring, loving, mutually supportive thirty-nine-year relationship with the tenor Peter Pears.)
***
Britten composed the quartet a number of months after visiting Bergen-Belsen and enjoying with Yehudi Menuhin for liberated prisoners of the Nazi camps. He had spent the primary a part of World Conflict II in america, and upon returning to the UK registered as a conscientious objector. He spoke little concerning the journey to Germany, however Peter Pears stated a lot later that it coloured all the things Britten wrote afterwards. When the quartet premiered, the proceeds have been donated to a fund for survivors of the 1943 Bengal famine, a humanitarian catastrophe brought on by the criminally exploitative and neglectful British colonial authorities, with Winston Churchill at its head.
The quartet can also be described as sturdy.
***
Different adjectives employed by music writers for the quartet: austere, uncanny, misty, magnificent, sly, darkish, tantalizing, stressed. I’ve to confess it sounds significantly good performed on lately of frantic autumn wind.
***
There are dry disgusted bits and straining tender bits. Generally the quartet appears to overlook about magnificence for minutes at a time—will get taken over by defiant cruelty and cheerful dread—after which abruptly remembers it in a shaft of damp daylight. (On this manner it’s faintly recognizable as “English.”)
There are weird bits and frenetic bits and grinding decided bits. It feels one thing like attempting to outrun a migraine, which I can do typically with caffeine and a chilly bathe and maintaining busy however which is all the time a set of blind ways in opposition to my physique’s favourite thriller. Laborious to listen to the sharp C main chords as something however the migraine’s triumphant stabs of ache.
***
The quartet was formally composed as a tribute to Henry Purcell: the final motion is a set of variations referred to as a chacony (or chaconne), an previous dance kind. Variations demand a selected consideration, every time: discover the theme, then discover the range. After the theme is acknowledged, there are twenty-one variations. Strive counting them!
One variation has a cello line like a person turning over in his sleep. One other feels like a methodical sorting, arraying, and cataloguing of our souls in all their varied elements. One other is a jolly dying practice chugging out of a station.
On the finish of the ultimate variation it rolls again into C main and declares, I instructed you I knew the way in which. All of the passengers are inexperienced and shivery with movement illness, however nonetheless, we’re house.
—Rosalind Brown, writer of “A Slender Room”
Partly legible notes scribbled whereas engrossed within the dance efficiency choreographed by Moriah Evans at Efficiency House New York within the winter of 2022 are my solely documentation of Stays Persist. This was a durational affair lasting 4 hours during which 9 performers, appearing as both analysis topics or examiners, carried out a collection of timed, extremely structured duties. These duties corresponded to 2 sorts of analysis, which Evans, within the present textual content, refers to as “stays research” and “resignation research.” Each occur via motion in actual time: the previous consists of “excavating the physique” to find the stays of one thing lodged inside, and the latter outcomes from accepting “one thing inevitably current however invisibilized within the physique.”
Earlier than being assigned a sort of research to conduct, every performer was queried by others enjoying the position of examiners, who requested the “topic” questions centered totally on their physique’s relationship to reminiscence, management, and narrative of the self, amongst them:
Is the physique disciplined?
How did the self educate the physique?
Is a part of your flesh in another person’s flesh?
Would you describe the self as chaotic or well-maintained?
Does the physique really feel completely satisfied?
What does the physique must say proper now?
What stuff are you all the time carrying with you?
Whereas answering these questions, the topic carried out actions that appeared to radiate from the interior organ or physique half being focused by the research. All through the efficiency, varied instructions have been repeated, with variations, by alternating performers: Provoke speech. Resume your organ work! Dance with and from the stays! After every spherical of duties, the performers would swap roles and begin over once more.
Rapt as I used to be for the present’s total length, I’ve by no means been extra conscious of my expendable situation as an viewers member. Performers have been really at work, plumbing their bodily and psychic interiors, they usually appeared involved with being witnessed by the viewers solely circumstantially. Poet that I’m, I are typically skeptical of seductively obscure catchphrases regarding “writing from the physique.” Right here, this occurred to be precisely what was unfolding earlier than me. The deliriously vivid speech that the performers produced on the spot as a part of these research surprised me. This was unrepeatable language opening up their our bodies, reworking them earlier than our eyes, bestowing on them an stubborn, distinctive, all-too-human dimension. This was ecstatic writing produced by our bodies in a trance whose defenses have been pulverized, revealing the terrifying reality of an innermost language—proof that the self is as a lot written and underwritten by the physique as the opposite manner round.
In fact, Evans didn’t search to regulate the viewers’s comings and goings. Individuals might transfer round, go away the theater and are available again later, however in this system notes, she warned: “The longer you keep, the nearer you get to theater.” By the top of the present, the performers had grow to be characters in a play with whom I’d skilled a variety of feelings as an alternative of virtuosic figures whose stamina and mastery over their our bodies in movement I couldn’t however admire. (Though there was that, too.) What they provided was catharsis—the spectacle of the physique therapeutic itself via the method of ejecting the tales and verbiage our bodies have a tendency to carry. Who stated such a verbal outpouring has to stay relegated to drama or poetry?
Dance with and from the stays! It’s all we are able to ever do if we let the physique have a good time the exuberance of its personal capability to maneuver itself and others.
Because it occurs, when you’re on the West Coast, you may catch the present at this time or tomorrow on the Museum of Up to date Artwork in Los Angeles.
—Mónica de la Torre, writer of “Flip Facet”
