That is a kind of subjects that may make you uncomfortable, particularly in case you’re an American and residing in France, as a result of possibly you’ve skilled precisely what I’m going to speak about. However we have to speak about it as a result of it’s a MAJOR cultural distinction. Right here it’s: Do NOT advocate for your self on the physician in France the identical manner you’d in america. There’s a manner you’ll want to strategy issues and a purpose behind it, so learn on…
OK, saying “don’t advocate for your self” wants some context as a result of a blanket assertion like that may result in confusion or defensiveness, so let me say this proper off the bat: This isn’t about telling folks to just accept dangerous care, ignore their our bodies, or keep silent when one thing is incorrect.
It’s about understanding that what advocacy appears to be like like is deeply cultural… and in France, it appears to be like very totally different than what chances are you’ll be used to.
I additionally need to say that what I speak about right here is one thing I’ve made sense of after residing in France for over a decade, each with my very own care and the care of the folks round me. I can now higher articulate what I’ve observed, so my observations aren’t about one physician’s go to.
It additionally doesn’t imply each physician goes to have the identical mindset, persona, or ego, so we are able to’t put everybody in the identical field or generalize saying we’ll all have the identical expertise. Life doesn’t work like that anyplace.
However there are some overarching cultural factors you’ll want to bear in mind when going to the physician in France. None of them negate the truth that I like France’s healthcare system general. An enormous plus is that your medical health insurance isn’t tied to your job in France and an accident gained’t bankrupt you. However anyway, I’m digressing.
So now that that’s out of the way in which, right here’s what I’ve observed. It’s one thing to be very conscious of when in search of out medical care in France.
Within the American medical system, you’re a part of the crew.
Adore it or hate it, medication is a enterprise in america, an enormous one, and one which’s a part of the service trade.
Healthcare is dear, insurance coverage could be sophisticated, and sufferers are continually reminded that they’re prospects. You’re inspired to analysis, ask questions, and hunt down second opinions. In different phrases, advocating for your self is a part of the method.
Medical doctors are sometimes seen as collaborators. You and your physician are on the identical crew, working collectively to determine subsequent steps. If you’re inquisitive about a selected take a look at or remedy, you may ask typically. You may not all the time get it, however asking is regular and even anticipated. It’s a dialog.
After which there’s the promoting.
Prescription drug advertisements direct to client are in every single place within the U.S. Watching a 30-minute Jeopardy episode will inform you all about medicine and their unwanted side effects for issues like eczema and psoriasis remedies, diabetes, weight reduction, and even prEP (pre-exposure prophylaxis). My dad and I joke about all of the advertisements and their record of 100 unwanted side effects once we watch TV collectively. The sort of promoting is illegitimate in every single place however the U.S. and New Zealand.
Right here’s the purpose I need to make. Within the U.S., you’ll hear the narrators say one thing on the finish like, “Ask your physician right this moment if X is best for you.”
The message is evident: YOU needs to be driving the dialog. You have got the proper to ask for a drugs and are inspired to take action. You can also make selections about your well being. You may have a dialog together with your physician about it.
In France, there are not any shiny journal spreads for medicine. No TV commercials itemizing unwanted side effects at lightning pace. No cultural norm of sufferers being “knowledgeable” by pharmaceutical corporations. Sure, you may even see over-the-counter drug advertisements and different pharmacy merchandise however no pharmaceuticals.
So when an American affected person asks for a selected drug in France, it doesn’t sound empowered, it sounds annoyingly suspicious.
The doc is considering, “Do you assume you already know higher than me? How dare you! Why would you like that drug? The place did you hear about it? Why are you questioning my judgment?”
Now, I’m not inserting a worth judgment on whether or not or not that is proper or incorrect, however the reality is that Individuals are very accustomed to asking their docs for precisely what they need, similar to suggesting a drugs they noticed on TV. It cuts to the chase and doesn’t waste time, if you’ll solely have a couple of minutes with the doc anyway. This may create a disconnect or perhaps a misunderstanding in France, or on the very least, get your appointment began off on the incorrect foot.
And yeah, the drug would possibly make it easier to, certain. However it’s additionally a enterprise within the U.S.
France doesn’t see medication this fashion.
France doesn’t deal with healthcare like a market.
Medical doctors usually are not service suppliers competing on your satisfaction. They’re authorities. Skilled specialists. Gatekeepers. And culturally, they’re positioned above the affected person, not beside them. That is REALLY essential to know. And a few docs take this to a complete new degree. Egos for daysssssss.
Make no mistake, this hierarchy just isn’t refined.
In France, the physician decides:
* Which exams are essential
* Which medicines are acceptable
* Whether or not one thing is ‘price’ treating proper now or warrants being appeared into additional
*Whether or not what you’re saying is legitimate or needs to be dismissed, case closed, with out additional investigation.
Your function is to elucidate your signs clearly and truthfully… after which hear.
In the event you stroll right into a French physician’s workplace requesting a selected remedy, take a look at, or remedy, particularly one you examine or noticed marketed, chances are you’ll instantly lose credibility.
It’s not since you’re incorrect. However with out figuring out it, you’ve violated an unstated rule. The physician is in cost. It is a main French cultural distinction and isn’t all the time noticeable instantly. However it’s there.
Within the French system, data appears to move downward. And this angle doesn’t simply prolong to sufferers asking for a selected remedy. It additionally extends to asking about alternate diagnoses, higher explanations, and pushing again on something the physician has mentioned.
I’m a agency believer in the truth that I do know my physique greatest. I believe it’s regular to ask questions (after all respectfully) however generally docs appear actually triggered and such as you’re strolling on eggshells.
Let me inform you a fast story. I’ve a member of the family right here in France who has a medical situation and at some point we had a video appointment with a specialist they’d been already seeing for a 12 months. The appointment was exhausting to get and included a number of months of ready.
Now, my member of the family is modest and downplays their signs and struggles. In an effort to be upfront with the physician, I attempted to talk up and reiterate that my member of the family was struggling greater than they let on so she might perceive the severity of what they have been coping with. I used to be advocating for a beloved one.
Effectively, I bought out half of my sentence earlier than she overreacted within the craziest manner I’ve ever seen. She went on a rant for atleast 2 minutes earlier than we might get a phrase in. As an alternative of letting me end, she assumed I used to be going to say that my member of the family was struggling and that she wasn’t doing sufficient to assist. A whole meltdown on her half is what adopted. That’s NOT what I used to be going to say in any respect, however she wouldn’t let me end.
She as a substitute minimize me off and mentioned she was dropping my member of the family as a affected person efficient instantly and screamed at us to by no means contact her once more. She then ended the decision earlier than we might even get a phrase in.
What within the precise heck was that?!?!?! We have been shocked. We felt so defeated after that that we simply cried, fully devoid of any hope. Beginning with a brand new specialist took eight months of ready.
Even when I had mentioned I didn’t really feel she was doing sufficient, which I undoubtedly DID NOT DO, there’s a manner to reply to a affected person and a solution to go fully overboard. I barely bought out 10 phrases and wasn’t even saying that and her response was the craziest one I’ve ever seen.
Might this have occurred within the U.S.? Certain. However it occurred in France. Dangerous experiences on the physician exist right here too.
Understanding your house could be exhausting to know, particularly when feelings and ache are concerned.
That is the half folks wrestle with most. And it’s not simply foreigners. Our nephew right here in France really needed to have his appendix eliminated after it burst. This was after visiting the ER a number of instances within the weeks prior. His dad requested for an inexpensive blood take a look at throughout these visits to verify what was happening however the request was dismissed.
He was scolded by a health care provider who mentioned one thing like, “Sir, this can be a public system. We will’t do exams willy nilly each time a child is available in with abdomen ache.” Oof. Our nephew suffered greater than he ought to have.
In France, you might be anticipated to “know your house” within the medical hierarchy… and that place is beneath the physician. However docs aren’t all the time proper. They aren’t infallible. They don’t know our our bodies higher than we do.
In the event you’re used to being assertive, collaborative, or proactive in healthcare settings, this may really feel infantilizing, irritating, and even unsafe. It may well really feel such as you’re being dismissed as a substitute of heard.
Once I noticed a health care provider for my very own challenge, there was one other occasion that left me in tears. And I’ve heard mannnnny extra tales like this from French folks I’ve talked to and by studying docs’ opinions on-line.
I’ll freely admit that as of late, after I go to the physician, I’m overly pleasant, subservient, and quiet. I generally have to elucidate why I’m sweating bullets. It’s a stress response I’ve developed from dangerous experiences even when the present physician is improbable.
None of that is an assault on French healthcare, so please don’t misunderstand me. I believe the system has so much going for it and is considered one of my high causes I love residing in France. Healthcare is a human proper and France will get that. I’ve had many nice docs’ appointments the place I’ve been heard and docs are collaborative, affected person, and type. However once more, this doesn’t imply the system is ideal or that totally different energy dynamics aren’t at play.
It does imply that approaching issues from an American perspective as a complete typically backfires and it’s so essential to know the totally different dynamics at play otherwise you’re going to be annoyed.
Advocacy exists, simply not the way in which you assume.
Right here’s the nuance that issues. Advocating for your self in France doesn’t appear like making calls for or requests. It appears to be like like persistence, precision, and endurance. And I’m not saying Individuals are all pushy and aggressive making all these calls for on the physician in U.S. By no means, it’s simply that the dynamic is totally different, and we want to pay attention to that. Being respectfully assertive which is ok typically within the U.S. may not be seen the identical manner right here.
In France, deal with doing this on the physician:
* Clearly describing signs with out dramatizing or self-diagnosing
* Returning if one thing doesn’t enhance, generally a number of instances, and coping with unlucky lengthy waits in lots of circumstances
* Asking why one thing is the way in which it’s gently, not FOR one thing like you might be owed it. Sure, this may really feel such as you’re tiptoeing round your physician, however it’s important to know how you can finesse the state of affairs and play the sport.
* Typically altering docs quietly is the easiest way to go if somebody isn’t a great match.
It’s much less about asserting your self and extra about navigating the system strategically. Which is a dance that may really feel exhausting, I get it, particularly in case you’re already worn down, in ache, sick, drained, scuffling with the language, waited months for the appointment, and many others.
For Individuals, particularly these used to collaborative care, the French system can really feel adversarial. And if you’re scared, in ache, or weak, that lack of management can really feel deeply unsettling. Belief me, I get that too.
Many foreigners overseas expertise medical tradition shock (no robe on the gyno, for one) and it’s not as a result of France lacks excellent care (it doesn’t)… however as a result of the facility dynamics are so totally different.
Neither system is 100% proper or incorrect. And for the document, the U.S. will get SO a lot incorrect.
The American system empowers sufferers — generally to their profit, generally to their detriment. The French system trusts docs — generally correctly, generally excessively.
Understanding this distinction doesn’t imply it’s important to prefer it. However it does make it easier to survive it — and get higher care inside it.
And sure, there are good and dangerous docs in every single place. Not each American physician is collaborative and never each French physician buys into this hierarchy. There’s all the time nuance, so I hope you perceive the place I’m coming from.
The underside line
In the event you stroll right into a French physician’s workplace anticipating American-style advocacy to work, you’ll doubtless depart annoyed, unheard, or labeled troublesome. In the event you stroll in understanding the cultural guidelines, you stand a greater probability of being taken severely.
So play by the principles. Politely be sure to’re heard. Get excellent care. And if it doesn’t go to plan, discover a new physician. There are various of them on the market.
***
Have you ever skilled what I’m speaking about right here with medical care in France?
P.S. Right here’s one other submit you would possibly like about healthcare variations in France vs. the U.S.
P.P.S. In case you’re curious, veterinary care in our expertise has been completely superb for the ten years we had Dagny. (She went into coronary heart failure every week after I misplaced my mother and handed away only a few months later and I’ve by no means been the identical.)
Whether or not it was our house vet (who I nonetheless go to really), a specialist close by or an emergency vet we needed to see on trip someplace, vet care was all the time collaborative, thorough, inexpensive, and type. I all the time felt heard and revered. I can’t say sufficient good issues about veterinary care in France and can be eternally appreciative of the superb care our candy Dagny obtained for her total life, particularly on the finish.
Dammit, I’m tearing up simply scripting this so I’m going to cease there. However yeah, grateful doesn’t even convey the quantity of affection I’ve for our vet and vets generally. Dagny, I like you and miss you day by day.
